As a second football week peters out, the CBE was given something that we haven't seen since winter ended... Some cooler weather. The perfect opportunity to drink some of the beers in the #CBE12 mix. I took full advantage of that. I was also watching some games while finishing up Part 2 of the newsletter, and most of it was constructed on an iPad, so I hope the formatting isn't completely ridiculous. And I don't know how pictures are going to work on this. I hope well, or at the very least acceptably.
From the trunk of newly minted parents, the first beer on the second part of this newsletter is
Smuttynose Pumpkin. I went through a few of these last season, and as far as pumpkin beers go, this one is interesting because it's not overwhelming. It's the Oktoberfest of pumpkin beers. Unlike the Weyerbacher and Dogfish Head, you can have a few of them and continue to enjoy football games all day. A lot of people say pumpkin doesn't taste like anything, and it's the spices that make a good pumpkin beer. To them, I say, pompion tastes like this...
Smuttynose Pumpkin Ale is our homage to the craft and heritage of America’s brewers. Recipes calling for the use of pumpkins in beer date back to early colonial times, when brewers sought to extend their supply of costly imported malt with locally grown ingredients, such as squash and “pompions.”
In that spirit, we brew our ale with the addition of pumpkin to the mash, along with traditional spices to create a delicious American original.

I've had more and more Southern Tier beers of late, and they're good. Harvest was kind of a gamble. Not a pumpkin, not an Oktoberfest. I figured it would be a hoppy and malty fall favorite. It actually tastes a little grapfruity to me. As far as fall seasonals, it definitely leans to the hoppy side. It's definitely something I'll be keeping an eye out for, as well as other offerings from Southern Tier. It's a great "change of pace" from some of the other CBE12 selections.
Harvest Ale is our celebration of the changing weather and the sowing of hops and barley that will be used in our upcoming brews. We usher in the fall with a classic English style Extra Special Bitter of the highest order. Deep ruby in color with an even deeper hop flavor… in fact, we throw fresh English hops into every brewing vessel, then dry hop after fermentation to impart a zesty kick. This beer has real hop character that mingles with fresh malted barley for an experience that will make you wish it were fall year ‘round.
Cisco Pumple Drumkin. If brewery's websites had any influence on beer ratings, this would be the worst rated beer of all time. Even worse than the Breckenridge Vanilla Porter. Luckily for Cisco, Nantucket, and the entire state of Massachusetts, that is not the case. The website is the worst. This one tastes like you should melt marshmallows on it and serve it as the sweet potato casserole at Thanksgiving dinner. It's definitely full bodied, lots of spices going on, but the spices seem a little more subdued than they do in some of the other pumpkin beers. This one tastes like putting a scoop of pumpkin guts into your yam when your about half way through emptying one out to carve some dopey three toothed face into one. It also has one of the coolest pumpkin beer labels.

Our Pumple Drumkin Ale is a fall favorite on the island. A deep orange hue and a subtle pie aroma meet a robust male character in this ale which, true to its seasonal reveling, tastes like toasted pie crust in your mouth. It will finish clean and dry on the palate and leave you wishing that every day could be autumn on Nantucket!
Uinta makes a black lager called Baba. As in black sheep. It comes in cans, and I drank some of it this summer. It's delicious. I was kind of hoping that the
Philly Brewing Company Schwarzinger was going to be like that. It is vaguely, but it's admittedly not as good. Oddly, none of the bottles that I've consumed have had any head retention. They were also kind of oddly tart. And not as roasty as I was hoping they would be. It's also new enough that there are not comprehensive ratings on any website to get an idea of how well it's being received. And the website only says...
A German style black lager brewed with premium pilsner and dark roasted malts.
I really enjoy a lot of PBC beers. The Newbold IPA is pretty good, the Joe Porter (coffee porter) is a favorite of mine. The Walt Wit is really great. I was hoping for more. Maybe next time.
Enjoy your football, enjoy the weather as it finally gets cool enough to actually enjoy these beers. Enjoy that CBE12 gave you two newsletters for the price of one. Keep an eye out for Souther Tier Pumking, Stevens Point Whole Hog Pumpkin and Williamsberg AleWerks Pumpkin Ale. Those will stand up to any of the pumpkins in CBE12.